Working paper · November 2026 · Field evidence from Brazil

Brazil has the e-waste. Steady supply to Europe fails at the last mile: collection cost, records and who pays. An operator's view since 2008.

Marcio Villanova · Founder, Villanova ESG | CEO, Ecobraz · In Brazil's e-waste field since 2008.
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24429432 · Licence: CC BY 4.0

How to read the tags

Every claim carries a tag. Fact: verifiable source or public record. Interpretation and field observation: the operator's reading, from operation since 2008. Thesis: the argument of this paper, to be tested with buyers and funders.

The buyers are already looking

Every week, buyers from outside Brazil write to us asking for e-waste: circuit boards, mixed scrap, batteries. Most are traders from outside Europe. Almost all of them ask the same question: how much ready material can you ship? (Fact, from our inbox. Interpretation: the demand exists; the supply they look for does not.)

Why the answer is always “less than you think”

The volume does not sit in scrap yards. It sits in homes, small offices, schools and branch networks, a few devices at a time. A yard sells what reached it, after the informal chain has taken the easy value. A buyer who starts at the yard gate gets what is left. (Interpretation, from operation since 2008.)

Household equipment that never reaches a licensed operator stays in drawers, goes out with ordinary rubbish, is left on the street for waste pickers, or ends up in dumps. (Field observation.)

The material has also changed since 2011. Older equipment was built with more of the valuable metals than today's devices. (Field observation.) Published studies point the same way: gold and silver in the circuit boards of mobile phones made between 1998 and 2021 fell year on year (Jandric et al., Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 2026), and earlier work on boards from discarded computers found the same decline (Bizzo et al., Materials, 2014). Not every part follows the trend: in memory modules, gold and silver stayed stable while palladium fell by 80% between 1991 and 2008 (Charles et al., Waste Management, 2017). (Fact, with sources.) So the units that have waited longest in drawers tend to be the richest, and the hardest to reach. (Interpretation.)

The last mile is where the cost sits

Collecting a few devices from thousands of addresses costs more, per kilo, than the scrap is worth in most lots. That is why traders do not go there, and why opportunistic buying rarely turns into steady supply. (Interpretation, from operation.)

What the operation taught

The business started from a problem. In 2008 we rented IT equipment for trade fairs and congresses in São Paulo. When the 2008 crisis emptied the events calendar, we were left with a stock of ageing computers and no use for it. We tested recycling with the oldest units, then put up a website and ads to see who searched for the service. Both households and companies did. We chose companies, for volume, and spent three years on licences and paperwork, to work the opposite way from the informal scrap dealer. Ecobraz began operating in 2011. (Fact: Marcio's history.)

For years we spent heavily on active sales. It did not pay. Nobody wants to hear from a disposal company until they have a problem, so clients come to the operator, not the other way round. (Interpretation, from operation.)

Each collection also carries risks the price does not show. The client has no contract and no obligation. A truck sent for a “large volume” finds a load that fits in a car boot. “Electronics” turn out to be contaminated material that costs money to dispose of. Equipment disappears before the truck arrives, because staff took it home. A client cancels after the visit has been prepared. The operator carries each of these costs. (Interpretation, from operation.)

What lowered our cost was not checking every client more. A client asked for photos and forms simply moves to the next provider. What worked was learning the warning signs and asking for more only when a request shows them. (Interpretation. The list of signs stays private.)

Why spot buying does not become supply

Buying 100 tonnes from Brazil once is easy. Buying 100 tonnes every month is not. Brazilian scrap dealers live from this trade, and every week someone new offers a higher price. A buyer who arrives with no local structure, no documentation and no relationship takes a lot or two, then loses it to the next buyer who pays more. Running their own collection is out of reach, because the last-mile cost makes it prohibitive. (Interpretation, from operation since 2008.)

Steady supply needs what spot buying lacks: a tie between buyer and operator that holds when someone else offers more next week. In practice, the European buyer funds the Brazilian operator's last mile. In return, everything collected and processed is sold to that buyer, and the disposal records travel with it. Run from a few regional hubs where the volume is, this gives the buyer a recurring flow with its paperwork, and takes it out of the price war with buyers who come for one lot. (Thesis.)

The structure already exists in small form. Ecobraz's Adote um Bairro programme, listed as a good practice on the European Circular Economy Stakeholder Platform, is funded by corporate sponsors: Ecobraz runs collection and environmental education in a São Paulo neighbourhood, sorts the equipment and sends it to reuse or treatment. (Fact: public programme description.) Tying the funder to the processed material is the step that turns it into supply. (Thesis.)

For a European group whose own IT equipment or sold products end their life in Brazil, those records can also feed its value-chain (Scope 3) reporting. For a recycler that only buys material, the value is the material. (Interpretation, to test with buyers.)

Who can pay for the last mile

Not the material. The parties that carry obligations:

  • Brazilian manufacturers and importers of household electronics, who carry the legal duty for final destination under Decree 10.240/2020, largely through managing entities. (Fact.)
  • Companies that retire IT equipment holding personal data, which must keep that data secure under Brazil's LGPD and, for European groups, the GDPR. (Fact.)
  • The largest European groups, which must report on their value chains under the CSRD. Since the 2026 Omnibus, that means companies with more than 1,000 employees and more than EUR 450 million in turnover. (Fact.)

Companies already carry part of this cost, often without seeing it. The common mistake when a large company retires IT equipment is to hire whoever pays most for it. That provider skips what costs money: destroying drives, disposing correctly of what cannot be reused. (Interpretation, from operation.) Under Brazil's solid waste law, hiring a contractor does not release the generator from liability for damage caused by improper handling of its waste. (Fact: Law 12.305/2010, art. 27.) Data left on the drives stays the company's problem as well. (Interpretation.)

Paper is not proof either. In São Paulo, the transport manifest (MTR) and the certificate of final destination (CDF) are issued in SIGOR, the online system of the state environmental agency, CETESB. (Fact.) We regularly hear from companies under environmental inspection holding a certificate from a provider that never issued the manifest in the system. That certificate has no value. (Interpretation, from operation.)

The same pattern shows up in inspections and court cases: a company is asked to prove what happened to equipment it no longer holds, and only records issued in the system answer the question. (Interpretation, from operation.)

The principle: when collection is paid as a compliance service, the material arrives as a by-product, with its paperwork attached. (Thesis. Costs and prices stay private.)

Three parties, one flow

The arrangement that holds has three parties, and each pays from a budget it already has. (Thesis.)

  • A European group with operations in Brazil funds the last mile. Its anchor is the disposal of its own IT equipment in Brazil, with data destruction and chain of custody: an obligation it already carries under the LGPD, the GDPR and Brazil's solid waste law. Where it sells electronics in Brazil, part of its take-back duty under Decree 10.240/2020 can run through the same flow. It can also fund household collection in the cities where it operates. In return it receives records per collection: data for its own waste and end-of-life reporting, and proof of data destruction.
  • A European recycler signs for all the processed material, with a minimum volume and a price formula. It gets steady feedstock with its paperwork.
  • A licensed Brazilian operator runs the last mile: collection, sorting, records per collection and per funder, and export under the Basel Convention, which requires authorisation from Brazil's environmental agency, IBAMA, and the consent of the importing country. (Fact.)

Someone has to hold the three together and keep the evidence auditable from the first collection to the European buyer's file. That is the role Villanova ESG is built for. (Thesis. Costs, prices and eligibility rules stay private.)

What Europe gets

Steady volume instead of lots. Documentation per collection (transport manifest, certificate of final destination, inventory) that a European buyer can audit. A supply that does not depend on outbidding the next trader. This matters to EU recyclers at a time when the Critical Raw Materials Act sets a non-binding 2030 benchmark: recycling capacity equal to at least 25% of the EU's annual consumption of strategic raw materials. (Fact.)

The question for European recyclers and investors

Brazil has the material. The question is who pays to bring it to the yard, and with what proof. Those who answer it will have supply. The rest will keep bidding for leftovers.

What this paper does not disclose

This paper sets out the problem and the principle. Costs, prices, eligibility rules and the mechanics of the model are not disclosed. No client case is described: every Ecobraz collection carries a signed confidentiality term.

Competing interests. The author is the CEO of Ecobraz Emigre, a Brazilian e-waste and ITAD operator, and the founder of Villanova ESG, an EU-Brazil regulatory-risk advisory. The three-party flow described here includes the role of a Brazilian operator, a role Ecobraz performs. No client data, no prices and no data from third-party assignments are used.

References

  • Bizzo, W. A., Figueiredo, R. A., & de Andrade, V. F. (2014). Characterization of printed circuit boards for metal and energy recovery after milling and mechanical separation. Materials, 7(6), 4555–4566. https://doi.org/10.3390/ma7064555
  • Charles, R. G., Douglas, P., Hallin, I. L., Matthews, I., & Liversage, G. (2017). An investigation of trends in precious metal and copper content of RAM modules in WEEE: Implications for long term recycling potential. Waste Management, 60, 505–520. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2016.11.018
  • Jandric, A., Ginzinger, L., Vrucak, D., Latacz, D., Shaik, K., Gießmann, T., de Souza, R. G., Mangunda, C., Birich, A., & Salhofer, S. (2026). Material composition trends in printed circuit boards of mobile phones. Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 227, 108741. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.resconrec.2025.108741
  • Brazil. Law No. 12.305 of 2 August 2010, National Solid Waste Policy, art. 27.
  • Brazil. Decree No. 10.240 of 12 February 2020, reverse logistics of household electrical and electronic products.
  • Brazil. Law No. 13.709 of 14 August 2018, General Data Protection Law (LGPD).
  • European Union. Regulation (EU) 2016/679, General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR).
  • European Union. Regulation (EU) 2024/1252, Critical Raw Materials Act.
  • European Union. Directive (EU) 2022/2464, Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD), as amended by the 2026 Omnibus simplification package.
  • Basel Convention on the Control of Transboundary Movements of Hazardous Wastes and their Disposal (1989).
  • CETESB. SIGOR, online system for solid waste management, State of São Paulo.

How to cite: Villanova, M. (2026). Brazil's e-waste and the last mile: why spot buying does not become supply for European recyclers. Working paper, version 1.0. Villanova ESG. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24429432.